Warning: call_user_func() expects parameter 1 to be a valid callback, no array or string given in /home/swellvegan/swellvegan.com/wp-content/plugins/akismet/widget.php on line 126

Warning: session_start(): Cannot send session cookie - headers already sent by (output started at /home/swellvegan/swellvegan.com/wp-content/plugins/akismet/widget.php:126) in /home/swellvegan/swellvegan.com/wp-content/themes/modularity/functions/admin-js.php on line 2

Warning: session_start(): Cannot send session cache limiter - headers already sent (output started at /home/swellvegan/swellvegan.com/wp-content/plugins/akismet/widget.php:126) in /home/swellvegan/swellvegan.com/wp-content/themes/modularity/functions/admin-js.php on line 2
VeganMoFo: Vegan Haggis – A Story – swell

VeganMoFo: Vegan Haggis – A Story

If you know what true haggis is, you know why I’m not going to go into a description of it and then try to justify the need for a vegan version or if you can even call it haggis when it’s vegan.  And if you don’t know what it is, I’m sparing you the horrible details of Scotland’s national dish which has a mass-produced vegetarian (vegan) version on the market that was initially developed on a dare and now, I’ve heard, makes up 25% of the one of the major haggis producers sales.

Why do I know about haggis?  As college student recently done with my freshman year, I was struggling to figure out who I was and why I loved/hated boys (not for the usual reasons, turns out I was gay!) and didn’t have a family to go home to on holidays.  So I made the semi-rash decision to go backpacking on my own in the UK and Ireland and Sweden for 7 weeks (7 weeks!), where I saw all manner of amazing sights, learned a lot about myself (like living out of a backpack for that amount of time is lonely and wearing), and completely, utterly fell in love with Scotland.  I was vegetarian at the time, so I’ve never actually eaten the haggis, though I distinctly remember surviving largely on digestive biscuits with Scottish cheddar for a large portion of my bus and train travel around the country.

I loved Scotland so much I decided I had to study abroad there, and ended up spending a term there one year later at the Glasgow School of Art, back when I was an interior design student.  A friend of mine from Minnesota was studying in London and he came up to visit Scotland.  We traveled to Glencoe and hiked in the forests and hills and stayed in an old youth hostel, where we cooked our dinner in the large communal kitchen, and he had decided to buy canned haggis, which really isn’t very traditional either.  But it seemed pretty harmless in that form.  Last year when I went to visit my sister I got to try McSween’s veggie haggis as well as a mind-blowingly amazing homemade version at a small restaurant on the Isle of Skye.  I knew I someday wanted to make it at home – really, it’s just oats and protein and some veggies with fairly minimal seasoning.  But there aren’t a ton of recipes online, and many of them use tvp or veggie grounds, and I wanted to make a soy-free version (my version can also be made gluten-free, if you have gf oat products at hand).

This is my first attempt, and I think I’d like to change a few things about it for the future, as I think it could make a really great Thanksgiving entree with some sage and things.  It’s very filling, simple and savory, though a bit mild — a rich and/or tangy sauce akin to what I made for it really jazzes it up.  Traditional Scottish seasoning is a bit of a joke amongst people “in the know” as it were… usually you get a laugh and a recommendation for salt and pepper.  I added some cloves and nutmeg, and deglazed the pan with a little bit of whisky to add a little more Scottishness and depth, but that’s optional.  This makes a hearty loaf (rather than a more traditional wrapped or encased dish, as I didn’t want to deal with any potential failures there), so feel free to halve it if you try it out.  Mix up the nuts and root veggies for different variations, or add different seasonings — it’s almost like that mix and match vegan loaf website.  Using a food processor for each of the steps reduces the amount of fine hand chopping a

I’m not including a sauce recipe because I didn’t really measure anything and I wasn’t sure what was going to happen.  But what I did was throw a handful of ground cherries into a small pot with half a bottle of red wine, a few black peppercorns, and a big splash of balsamic vinegar, and cooked it down while the loaf was baking.  It was really yummy, though a tart cranberry sauce or other red wine-based sauce would do equally well.  Without further ado, I give you soy-free, gluten-free (option) vegan haggis…

Vegan Haggis (makes one large loaf)


1/2 c brown lentils, cooked in 1 1/2 c water, and mashed or pureed

1 15 oz. can kidney beans, rinsed, drained, and mashed or pureed

2 tbsp olive oil

1/2 c steel cut oats (can be gf)

1 c rolled oats (can be gf)

3/4 c finely chopped mixed nuts (I used walnuts, almonds, and hazelnuts)

3/4 lb. onions, diced

1 1/2 c root vegetables, finely chopped (I used carrots and sunchokes)

1/2 lb. mushrooms, finely chopped

1 vegan bullion cube (a vegan “beef” bullion works nicely here)

1/2-1 tsp freshly cracked black pepper

1/8 tsp cloves

1/4 tsp nutmeg

1 tsp salt

2 tbsp Scottish whisky (optional)

Heat the olive oil in a large cast iron skillet or other pot large enough to hold the oat, nut, and vegetable mixture.  Add the oats and nuts and toast until fragrant, then add the onions and cook until tender and starting to brown.  Stir in the root vegetables and mushrooms and cook, stirring to prevent sticking, until soft and reduced in volume.  Break up the bullion cube into the mixture, then season with pepper, cloves, nutmeg and salt, adjusting to taste.  Deglaze the pan with whisky (or water) and combine with the kidney and lentils in a large mixing bowl.

While the mixture is cooking, preheat the oven to 350 and lightly oil a loaf pan.  Fill the pan with the mixture and press in, smoothing the top.  Cover tightly and bake for 45-50 minutes, or until baked through (it may be slightly crumbly when you cut it).  Serve hot with sauce or gravy, and mashed potatoes (or turnips!) and cabbage.

28 Responses to “VeganMoFo: Vegan Haggis – A Story”

  1. This is VERY impressive! Really, what a creative way to make vegan haggis, I love it! Isn’t Scotland a beautiful country? I love it more every time I go back….except for the freezing cold, I will never love that!

  2. Nora says:

    like i said on flickr, you’re amazing! this touches my heart. i’m sure it’s better than the vegan haggis i had when i was there!

  3. Oooh I LOVE McSween’s Haggis – and this recipe of yours excites me no end.

  4. Lauren says:

    Never had haggis! Looks and sounds yummy!!

  5. Ricki says:

    I’ve never had haggis, but smelled it once (does that count?). This looks phenomenal. I HAVE to make this for the holidays! Right now I’m still off mushrooms and am wondering what, if anything, might be substituted. Any ideas?

  6. Andrea says:

    Fortunately, I’ve never had real haggis. I’ve never had vegan haggis either but now I think maybe I should. This sounds really good. It does remind me of a mix-and-match loaf I used to make from a Seventh Day Adventist cookbook I have — except maybe for the whiskey!

  7. Stephanie says:

    I fell in love with Scotland on my honeymoon! We had veggie haggis at a place called 13th Note, and I’ve been obsessed with making it since. Thank you for providing another version for me to try!

  8. kim says:

    Ricki – I’ve tried to figure out the mushroom substitution thing too on some other dishes! The first thing I came up with is bits of eggplant – since they are watery, spongy, and dense, I thought the texture could be rather like mushrooms if prepared correctly. Would zucchini work? Since it has kind of a spongy texture, it might work too.

    A-K – I love this post! Great writing, good storytelling. And beautiful photos and recipe. This looks great, I am also trying to figure out how to make this me-friendly : ) No kidney bean, oats, mushrooms, or most nuts for me right now, but I’m thinking red beans, whole sorghum grain, rice flakes, and sunflower and pumpkin seeds might do the trick. I’ll keep you posted! You are getting a link in my big Holiday food recipe round up post for sure with this one!

  9. Jes says:

    The haggis looks beautiful and like something I’ll need come January when I’m freezing!

  10. I’ve never had haggis but I do love nut loaves and this one looks grand! Congrats on the successful attempt and beautiful pictures!

  11. Mary says:

    FanTAStic! I tried vegetarian haggis while I was in Scotland (also one of my favorite places in the world), and I’m so excited to be able to make a gluten-free vegan version at home!

  12. Mo says:

    I tried vegan haggis last year for MoFo and I totally love the stuff. Not at all what I expected it to be. Yours looks way more fabulous than mine ever could.

  13. mihl says:

    I never had haggis but read about it on several vegan blogs….and of course your vegan version sound totally awesome. Even if I was an omni (which is hard to imagine) I would refuse to eat the original version, I guess.

  14. Erin says:

    Regardless of what it’s called, this sounds absolutely delicious!

  15. [...] You all were so inspiring and now I’ve got a long list of recipes to catch up on: A-K’s Vegan Haggis, Lazy Smurf’s Sanguine Moon Curry, Monica’s Carrot & Walnut Tofu Neatballs, Chow [...]

  16. I never thought I’d hear “vegan” and “haggis” together. This dish looks really impressive.

    I didn’t like the taste of haggis when I tried it 15 years ago, but I would be willing to give this recipe a try. Adding dried, sweet fruits to any dish is enough to win me over.

    Scotland is so beautiful, and I found the Scottish to be really funny and nice. Did you buy a kilt while you were there? :-)

  17. Monica says:

    I just did a google search for vegan haggis and came across your blog. I am so excited to try your recipe! I studied abroad in Scotland this past summer and sampled the ubiquitous canned stuff, but this sounds waay better.

    Also: Glencoe may have been my favorite part of the trip. I want to go back and spend MUCH more time there! It is an incredible area.

  18. [...] that is the national dish of Scotland, but if you want to hear more about the inspiration, go here to Swell Vegan to hear her story and get this amazing recipe. Seriously, this is very very good, and while I am [...]

  19. [...] Edamame accompanied by some vegan haggis and a massaged kale [...]

  20. [...] made Swell Vegan’s Vegan Haggis, and it was a huge hit. Seriously, I knew it would be good, but I had no idea that my family would [...]

  21. a-k says:

    Scotland is the most beautiful country almost EVER, and the freezing cold doesn’t bother me now that I’ve spent almost 10 years in Minnesota!

  22. a-k says:

    You’re too sweet! I hope it IS better, if you decide to make it!

  23. a-k says:

    If you didn’t see Kim’s comment already, I’d definitely recommend eggplant for a similar texture! Or any neutral-tasting, soft sort of veggie that will stay moist.

Leave a Reply